Sam Bahadur: Meghna Gulzar’s crash course on how not to make a biopic, a dramatic reenactment of a Vicky-pedia page

It was especially unfortunate, therefore, to watch director Meghna Gulzar reduce her latest release, Sam Bahadur, to essentially a dramatic reenactment of Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw’s Wikipedia page. Completely lacking a plot, or any sort of narrative thread for viewers to latch on to, Sam Bahadur is a uniquely bizarre experience. It isn’t terrible in the same way as, say, Saina or Shabaash Mithu, but for entirely different reasons altogether. 

Also read – Animal: Sandeep Reddy Vanga’s craft is just as infantile as his politics; what does he want us to talk about next?

The movie takes a literal cradle-to-the-grave approach, which in Gulzar’s hands comes across less like a knowing acknowledgement of tropes and more like lazy writing. It wouldn’t be an exaggeration to say that virtually every scene in Sam Bahadur could theoretically be the first. And because the movie goes through an interminable cycle of setting up new conflicts every five minutes and then resolving them with the least amount of narrative heavy-lifting, it’s impossible to empathise with Sam, the character. He’s played by Vicky Kaushal in a performance so exaggerated that it reduces India’s first Field Marshal to one of those Army uncles that scold random strangers on the street for dragging their feet, or for having poor posture. 

Here’s the template in a nutshell: Sam is thrown into a new mess at the start of every scene. These conflicts range from genuine, life-threatening danger in war zones to something as low-stakes as figuring out the dinner menu. Sam Bahadur is the kind of movie in which the Parsis talk about dhansak, while the sole Tamilian talks about sambar. In one scene, Sam finds himself in an Argo-like situation at an airport without any electricity. Forget eliciting basic thrills, the manner in which this mini-episode is resolved is unintentionally funny. The Sam of this movie isn’t above theatricality, and he can’t resist making a grand show of his solution to the electricity problem. Almost like a magician, he seems to snap his fingers, and two parallel rows of previously unseen soldiers suddenly appear on either side of the runway, with flaming torches in their hands. The plane can take off, problem solved.

Sam Bahadur also reduces the entire plot of the three-hour Oppenheimer to literally one scene. A jealous superior accuses Sam of being an ‘anti-national’, following which Sam is made to appear before a tribunal. The staging, structure, and performances in this sequence are truly farcical. Not a single member of the tribunal actually believes that Sam could be guilty; instead, they smirk to themselves at his witticisms. Sam himself is confident of his innocence, which is fine, but it robs the moment of true drama.

This scene encapsulates everything that is wrong with Sam Bahadur as a movie. Not only does it shrink what could have been a compelling story into essentially 10 minutes, it positively challenges you to care. What you’re watching is a dry retelling of events; most definitely not cinema. Gulzar’s version of Sam is no different from a god. “Tumhe kisi mein problem nai dikhti, sab ache lagte hain,” his wife tells him in one scene. “Sab usse pyaar karte hain,” another character says about Sam later. How bland.

Compare this to the moral complexity that Mann brought to his portrait of Ferrari, a character whose quest for professional excellence was waylaid by his foibles as a human being. He had a secret second family, a son that he was reluctant to reveal to the world, and a grief so inexplicable that he could only express it to a tombstone. Steve Jobs in Boyle’s film was similarly walled-off; a character whose professional achievements were clouded by his determined refusal to acknowledge his illegitimate daughter. In First Man, Neil Armstrong developed an emotional armour so formidable after the loss of his infant child that he literally went to the moon to let it all out. And as one person on Twitter joked about Nolan’s blockbuster, men like Oppenheimer would rather almost destroy the world than seek therapy. Each of these movies picked a chapter or two in their subjects’ lives, and built entire narratives around them. 

Read more – While We Watched: Tragic Ravish Kumar documentary is the best war movie of the year

Sam Bahadur inspires neither jokes nor jubilation. This is the least interesting way to make a biopic, and no amount of showboating by Kaushal is able to elevate the movie into something more engaging.

Post Credits Scene is a column in which we dissect new releases every week, with particular focus on context, craft, and characters. Because there’s always something to fixate about once the dust has settled.