Premium
This is an archive article published on December 17, 1998

A lesson unlearnt

``We want to evolve an education system which can restore falling human and moral values. We want to develop a new generation which is br...

.

“We want to evolve an education system which can restore falling human and moral values. We want to develop a new generation which is brimming with nationalism, character, culture and values — a generation fully developed not only physically but mentally, intellectually and spiritually…A generation which can face challenges of modern life and struggle against exploitation and injustices. A generation committed to make the nation rich and cultured.”

As the above ambitious aims make clear, the controversial Kalpa Yojna which led to the sacking of Uttar Pradesh Education Minister Ravindra Shukla on December 5 was not about just Saraswati Vandana and Vande Mataram. As envisaged by the Uttar Pradesh Government, it meant major changes in syllabus and daily routine of schools.

And the state government had lost no time implementing the scheme. Within a month of its promulgation in July this year, the scheme was in place in more than 5,000 of the total 1.25 lakh primary schools in thestate. Teachers had been imparted special training for the purpose. But for the fatwa issued by internationally acclaimed Muslim theologist Maulana Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi, alias Ali Mian, to his followers to withdraw their wards from schools run by the Uttar Pradesh Government, the Kalpa Yojna would have gone on to cover other schools as well.

Story continues below this ad

Under the scheme, all state government schools would in effect become “Saraswati Shishu Mandirs”, which are run throughout the country by Vidya Bharati, a Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) outfit. Among other things, the singing of Saraswati Vandana during the morning assembly and Vande Mataram at the end of the day would become compulsory. (Shukla now says he meant any prayer and not particularly Saraswati Vandana).

The schools would also have a Bal Bharati, consisting of a president, vice-president, secretary, deputy secretary, senapati (commander) and up-senapati (deputy commander).

The Yojna also envisaged naming ofclassrooms in schools after great leaders (their names figured in a list attached as an annexure to the Kalpa Yojna draft). These classrooms were supposed to display a portrait of the leader after whom they were named as well as anecdotes from his life.

It does not require much effort to guess who figured in the list of great personalities, circulated by the State Council of Education, Research and Training (SCERT), along with the Yojna draft. It included: RSS founder Dr Hegdewar, Vir Savarkar, Subhash Chandra Bose, Shyama Prasad Mookerji (founder of Jan Sangh, the precursor to the BJP), and Din Dayal Upadhyay –among the great leaders; Swami Dayanand Saraswati, Swami Ramtirtha, Swami Ram Krishna Paramhans, Swami Vivekanand, Madan Mohan Malviya, Maharshi Arvind, Ishwar Chand Vidyasagar and Ram Mohan Rai — among the social reformers; and Namdev, Tukaram, Sant Gyaneshwar, Shankaracharya, Ballabhacharya, Chaitanya Mahaprabhu and Sant Hari Das — among the poets.

Story continues below this ad

Though a number of freedom fighters, someformer prime ministers and presidents and personalities like Mother Teresa and Mahatma Gandhi also found a mention, the list had a predominant saffron tinge.

The list of quotations supplied with the Kalpa Yojna cited stray sentences from the Bible and occasional quotes of Hazrat Ali or Mahatma Gandhi, but a long list of Sanskrit shlokas from the Vedas and Upanishads. One of the clauses even made it mandatory for students to chant “Bhojan Mantra” during recess.

The other instructions were: “Portraits of Ma Saraswati and Bharat Mata be kept in a respectful manner during morning prayers and during dispersal of the school…The portraits should be properly decorated.” The clause detailing the procedure for morning prayers, interval and dispersal was titled “Vandana, Madhyavkash and Visarjan”.

Even the architects of the scheme — the “experts” — were no surprise, most of them proponents of the RSS ideology. The team was led by Shukla himself, who is an RSS pracharak. The sackedminister proudly recalls how he had once rebelled against his father, a Congressman, for restraining him from attending RSS shakhas. Shukla had been a teacher at the RSS-run Saraswati Shishu Mandir in Hamirpur before jumping onto the political bandwagon. Another “expert” on the Yojna committee was also an RSS full-timer, Radhey Shyam Pandey.

Story continues below this ad

In the preamble of the Yojna draft, Shukla wrote: “The Yojna envisages school as a family. The school family will be expected to prepare a draft scheme to achieve physical and educational aims, the progress of which will be monitored by officials of the Education Department. The SCERT will draft a detailed outline of curriculum and extra-curricular activities to be performed every month. The draft will be made available to every school by the third week of every month through a magazine. Principals…will be responsible for procuring details of the scheme and getting it implemented every month.”

However, with the scheme backfiring, almost everyone isdenying responsibility for the controversy now. Ali Mian dealt the first blow when he asked Muslims to withdraw children from Uttar Pradesh government schools, declaring: “Idol worship is taboo in Islam. Our wards can’t sing Saraswati Vandana before a portrait of Goddess Saraswati.”

Shukla says he at no point made singing of Saraswati Vandana compulsory. “I only asked children to have regular prayers, not necessarily Saraswati Vandana. Even the (government order) issued in April last year (during Mayawati’s chief ministership) asks school administration to make children sing `Ish Vandana’ (prayer to God)…I have become the victim of a well-hatched conspiracy by corrupt bureaucrats.”

However, Shukla sticks to the demand for Vande Mataram, saying: “There is no outcry when the song is sung at the beginning of every Parliament and Assembly session, among others by Muslim MPs…The song finds a mention in the Constitution as well. So why such a hue and cry is being raised whenI made it mandatory for our children…Those opposing it are unpatriotic.”

Story continues below this ad

Chief Minister Kalyan Singh, who chose to dump both the Yojna and Shukla when matters heated up, washes his hands of too. He agrees that there was no mention of Saraswati Vandana in either the Yojna or any government order, but says the vandana mentioned to be performed before a portrait of Goddess Saraswati has to be Saraswati Vandana. “It is clear therefore,” he said in a 10-page clarification, “that Shukla did not send the correct status report to the Chief Minister and misled him, which is why he was sacked.”

Kalyan has even claimed that this was not the first time Shukla had not taken him into confidence. The Chief Minister says the sacked minister had issued an order on November 5 last year making worship of “Bharat Mata” compulsory in government schools in Uttar Pradesh, and that he had had to withdraw the order after a controversy erupted.

Kalyan insists the issue is not about VandeMataram or Saraswati Vandana but about the breach of a chief minister’s trust by a member of his cabinet. “Since the government order on (the) Kalpa Yojna issued by Shukla was unauthorised and irregular, it has been withdrawn,” his clarification said.

However, apart from others, even the RSS does not think the issue ends at that. It was discussed at a five-day chintan baithak (conclave) of the Sangh at Nagpur, where most participants justified the decision to make Vande Mataram compulsory in schools and decided to take the matter up with top BJP leaders.

Story continues below this ad

“How can they ban the Rashtra Geet? It was penned by the eminent poet Bankim Chandra Chatterjee to infuse patriotism among people during the freedom struggle…It’s relevant today and will remain so even tomorrow,” says a senior RSS leader.

Yojana’s plans

  • A prayer to be sung before a Goddess Saraswati idol during the morning assembly and Vande Mataram at the end of the day.
  • Classrooms to be namedafter great leaders. Portraits of these leaders as well as anecdotes from their life to be displayed in the rooms. (The list of great leaders attached to the Yojana draft had a pronounced saffron tinge, including RSS founder Dr Hegdewar, Vir Savarkar and Jan Sangh founder Shyama Prasad Mookerji).
  • Students to chant “Bhojan Mantra” during recess.
  • Portraits of Ma Saraswati and Bharat Mata to be kept in a respectful manner during morning prayers and during dispersal of the school.
  • Latest Comment
    Post Comment
    Read Comments
    Advertisement
    Advertisement
    Advertisement
    Advertisement