Premium
This is an archive article published on June 17, 2003

How does a foreigner turn Indian? Just ask Mulayam

It would be staggering to imagine there will be permanent enemies and permanent friends in politics. Yet, the statement made by Samajwadi Pa...

It would be staggering to imagine there will be permanent enemies and permanent friends in politics. Yet, the statement made by Samajwadi Party leader Mulayam Singh yesterday on Sonia Gandhi’s ‘‘Indianness’’ must send tectonic waves in the political field.

Consider this: After being part of the shouting brigade to disallow foreigners to hold a constitutional post, Yadav declared in Etawah, his home constituency in Uttar Pradesh, that he would diasagree with anyone calling Sonia a foreigner.

‘‘The SP has saved the country from foreign power’’
Mulayam, April 1999

‘‘Sonia’s foreign origin will be an issue in the next Lok Sabha poll’’
Mulayam, September 2002

Story continues below this ad

‘‘Sonia is a true Indian who has imbibed the spirit of the country and its culture in totality’’
Mulayam, June 2003

‘‘She is a true Indian who has imbibed the spirit of the country and its culture in totality,’’ he said, ‘‘and it is wrong to call Sonia a foreigner now, as she has learned the ethos of Indian culture.’’

Fired by this new emotion, he said when the BJP raised the ‘‘Sonia’s foreign origins’’ it was bereft of political ideas. ‘‘It is likely the BJP will fight the next election on the Indian-versus-foreigner issue,’’ he added.

It is a long, winding road the SP leader has travelled ever since April 1999, when he refused to support Sonia’s claim to lead an alternative government to the BJP-led NDA government, which had been toppled at the Centre by one vote. Yadav said he was peeved by the Congress’ arrogance to take him for granted when Sonia unilaterally declared she had the support of 272 MPs.

Story continues below this ad

Pushed to the corner by the offensive launched by the Congress, Yadav struck back when he declared at a press conference in Lucknow a month later, ‘‘The SP has saved the country from foreign power by refusing to extend unconditional support for a minority-Congress government led by Sonia Gandhi.’’

When asked if he was opposed to Sonia only because she was a ‘‘foreigner,’’ Yadav had said that ‘‘his party believed crucial posts like that of President, Vice-President, Prime Minister and Lok Sabha Speaker should not be held by a foreigner.’’

Party MP Mohan Singh had even moved a Private Member’s Bill to this effect in the winter session (1998) in Parliament. The SP leader lustily joined the chorus demanding for a constitutional amendment to disallow foreigners from occupying a constitutional post and even aligned with the National Congress Party (NCP), which was created by former Congressmen Sharad Pawar, P A Sangma and Tariq Anwar on the ‘‘foreigner issue.’’

Even when AIADMK Empress J Jayalalitha (who incidentally allied with the Congress to bring down the NDA Government) later said she would never ally with Congress if ‘‘foreigner’’ Sonia continued to lead the party, the SP leader rushed to agree with her.

Story continues below this ad

He came out in support of Jayalalitha when he stated, ‘‘Sonia’s foreigner origin will be an issue in the next Lok Sabha poll,’’ and that his ‘‘party would raise it.’’ This was in September, 2002. Hardly one year ago.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement