
Swadeshi-videshi. The debate rages on and on. Much Coke has flowed under the bridge, and the big Mac has been tamed. Yet we haven’t reached a conclusion. And probably never will. For, what is swadeshi and what is videshi? Can anyone really tell the difference? These thoughts came to me over the last two weekends for the reasons that I am about to relate.
Two weekends and two very different experiences. By now, everyone has heard about the return to Mumbai of the Hare Rama Hare Krishna girl. The incomparable Usha Uthup who once set The Talk Of The Town on fire with her deep voice and her inimitable showmanship. I was too young to be permitted into the smoky environs of a nightclub when Usha was doing her thing in Bombay two decades ago. I saw her, like most of us did, on television. But watching the sari-clad, gajra-swinging Uthup glide from Sinatra to Feelings and Hava Nagila with her customary panache at Not Just Jazz By The Bay last fortnight, I was reminded of a timeseemingly distant. A time when pop music was such a rare commodity that like gold and pencil boxes with Mickey Mouse pictures, it had to be smuggled in, hankered after and treasured.
Take a look. The next weekend, I was invited to witness another musical event. The invitation came from the enthusiastic and energetic Sweety Kapoor (Indian name, British accent). The event (“two nights of universal club culture”) was not at one but two places: the swanky split level Raspberry Rhinoceros in the suburbs with its dimly lit pool tables, and at the place with (as many say) the longest bar in Asia. Three Flights Up. The crowd was hip and international. Blonde ponytails, silver trousers, Kookai shirts and the ubiquitous Dolce & Gabbana handbag. But not just. There were also plenty of glittery bindis and henna tattoos around in keeping with the Madonna and No Doubt-inspired fad for the season. The music, from the backstreets of London, was representative of a new sound. There was Amar, the misleadingly named female singer with the smoky voice whose repertoire sounded like a cross between Asha Bhonsle and Suzanne Vega. And then there was a live, interactive set, a hypnotic, rising sound interspersed with references to Indian Airlines and put together by the drummer, Inna Most and a DJ known as State of Bengal. The message of the evening? “Embrace your own cultural atmosphere.”
Swadeshi or Videshi. Which is which. The fact, as our cultural keepers would do well to admit, is that neither has ever existed in isolation. In Mumbai that was once Bombay and India that was once Bharat, the only truth is and has always been Mixdeshi.