Letters to the EDITOR

As someone who takes care of a dearly loved one with schizophrenia...

Wrong picture

• As someone who takes care of a dearly loved one with schizophrenia, I am pained by the inaccurate and archaic undertone in an article on the mentally ill being abandoned by their families in ‘asylums’ ‘Cured but unwanted: trauma continues for asylum inmates’. Millions of families provide dedicated care to family members with mental illness as opposed to the few who abandon them. There are only 40 mental health facilities in India, which house about 500 people. But India has more than 65 million people with mental illnesses. It is important to point out that schizophrenia is treatable but not curable. A few lucky patients do go into remission but most have to take lifelong medication and need a lot of care and therapy. Families of people with mental illness must not be judged until one takes the trouble of stepping into their shoes. As it is, both the patients and their families have been neglected by successive governments. Families are left to fend for themselves with their limited resources, without knowing how to manage the episodes of psychosis, violence and attempts at suicide and with no insurance to meet the medical expenses. Most families adapt to grieving; very few abandon their family members. Harping on ‘abandonment by families’ in articles such as this is unfortunate, highly questionable and not fair to the millions of families who provide care.

— Rukmini Pillai

New Delhi

Payback time

•P.R. Chari’s ‘Year of Pay Commission correctives’ reveals a narrow, if not exclusive, concern for the civil services by posing the question: “Why are the Indian civil services losing their best and brightest prematurely?” While one does not deny that the brightest in any service of the government should be paid well, in this era of superior technologies, scientists, engineers and security personnel should be compensated adequately. Anyway, the fear is that most recommendations of Pay Commissions remain ‘essays’, barring the scales recommended. One hopes, this time the government means business when it accepts the report of the Sixth Pay Commission.

— M.K.D. Prasada Rao

Ghaziabad

Bad politics

Story continues below this ad

• This refers to ‘An Indianness that belongs to us all’. Had the reservation policy been responsive enough, it should have achieved its goals in 60 years. If we can improve the economic condition of people, irrespective of caste, creed and religion, the problem will be taken care of. For that, we need to take measures that enable the benefits of economic gains to percolate right up to the last segment of society. But bad politics disables good economics.

— Naval Langa

Ahmedabad

Modi’s mix

• Your editorial, ‘Moditva’s moment’, was a balanced analysis of Narendra Modi’s resounding victory and its implications for the Congress and the BJP. You rightly observed, “What Modi did was to combine his government’s achievements on the development front with an insistent play on Hindu anxieties and stamp the mix with a strong signature style.” Yes, that was the crux of his victory.

— Madhu R.D. Singh

Ambala