Premium
This is an archive article published on June 2, 2003

Reflections in Dal lake

The backdrop was the obvious message. It would have been near impossible to miss the significance of a Congress Chief Ministers’ Concla...

.

The backdrop was the obvious message. It would have been near impossible to miss the significance of a Congress Chief Ministers’ Conclave held by the side of the Dal lake in Srinagar. But the party wasn’t taking any chances. The announcement of quotas for students from J&K and for children of migrants from the state in professional courses in all the Congress ruled states was very obviously meant to rub in the happy symbolism, and it did. Having said that, it may not be an exaggeration to say that the meeting in J&K was most important for its agenda on Uttar Pradesh.

In this crucial election year, those old questions have acquired a new urgency: Is the Congress prepared to stitch up alliances with other parties? Can Sonia’s haughty party find it in itself to unbend enough, can it summon the requisite flexibility, to enter into an arrangement of political give and take? Will India’s oldest party finally read the writing on the wall? At Srinagar, Sonia Gandhi would appear to have given the most fulsome indications yet that the party is preparing to junk the Panchmarhi mindset, and not just for UP. It was hedged in by wait-and-sees, but the message was clear and, given the party’s recent history, startling: The Congress may be thinking of a grand alliance at the Centre after lending support for an alternative government in UP. But questions remain. Is this newly “open” mind on the question of alliances the sign of a refreshing maturity, or just an impatient plunge into the game of political make-and-break? For the sake of the party, and the nation, we hope the Congress has thought this through.

There are other issues as well on which we would urge more clarity from the Congress. Like whether or not the party is firmly behind Ashok Gehlot’s promise of upper caste quotas. At Srinagar, the Congress chief expediently deflected the ball into another court. Nothing new about it, she said, didn’t the Narasimha Rao government do it too? On the economic front, the Congress slogan of “Congress ka haath garib ke saath” is unexceptionable. But it has nothing to say on the lingering gap between the party’s populist rhetoric at the Centre and its governments’ brave attempts to modernise the economies in the states. Finally, while the Congress chief unequivocally commended Ashok Gehlot for calling a halt to Praveen Togadia’s march in Rajasthan, she was notably silent on Digvijay Singh’s “soft Hindutva” experiment in Madhya Pradesh. Just two days in Srinagar were too short a time, perhaps. Perhaps Congress worthies should be packed off for another brainstorming in another enchanting locale.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement