Munni badnaam hui and Sheila ki jawani were top of the charts in 2010. But the lukewarm response to this years Mit jaaye gham and Razia gundon mein phas gayi is a cause for concern for audience and filmmakers alike.
Munni,of the badnaam fame and Sheila,of the jawani fame,dominated every single topic of conversation last year. They also dominated the airwaves and topped all chartbuster lists. While Malaika Arora Khans Munni brings out your inner nautch-girl,Katrina Kaifs Sheila act can just be the signature-tune of your inner showgirl. Quite like their choreographer/creator Farah Khan,I too love Munni and Sheila equally.
This year,it was supposed to be Deepika Padukones turn as she snagged the most-wanted Dum Maaro Dum item song in Rohan Sippys film. Jaideep Sahnis lyrics raised many eyebrows. The song works as a rap but if nostalgia is what you hoped the song will rekindle then it doesnt do that. If you are the kind who watches a song rather than hears it,then Mit jaaye gham (as the Deepika number has been rechristened) might be your cup of tea. I like to sing my words and dance to them,which unfortunately hasnt happened with Mit jaaye gham. Deepika is lovely,the song has been shot fantastically but its just not the item song to which one can groove. Its not even Khakees Aisa jaado daala re,which was good campy fun.
Even the much touted Razia gundon mein phas gayi from Thank You didnt click as it was supposed to. Mallika Sherawats item song was publicised to be the next Munni but it didnt even come anywhere close to Dabanggs atomic jhatkas.
Then there is Yana Gupta doing the rustic version of Zeenat Amans Qurbani chartbuster,Laila main laila,in Chalo Dilli. I dont know about you but I much preferred Yana on top of a buffalo in Babuji zara dheere chalo. At least that was a new visual. This one just makes me want to go back to the original and see Zeenat Aman do her thing. By the way,whats with this sudden Zeenie-baby obsession? At this rate,it wont be long when someone will come up with a remix version of Satyam Shivam Sundaram. Shudder.
The audiences lukewarm response to the latest item songs seems worrisome. Is it time to hit the panic button? Has the item song gone bust? Have filmmakers overdone the item,stretched it so much that there is no novelty left? Or is it that repackaging old hits in their new-age avatar has become so banal that the audience is hitting the snooze button?
It can no longer be termed as fascination or tribute. B-towns obsession with everything retro is proof of its creative bankruptcy. Nobody wants to think of a fresh idea. Its like everyone wants to dip in the pool of the great 60s and 70s,and come out with a tune. Once they get the tune then all that is needed is to remix it,add some loud noise,some club beats,techno it up and voila,you have a new chartbuster. Repackaging seems to be the new word for composing.
For an item song to be a films USP,it needs to be unique to that film. Kajra re was Bunty Aur Babli. Beedi was Omkara. Chhamma chhamma was China Gate. Just like Dum maaro dum is Hare Rama Hare Krishna. Period. The moment the RD Burman guitar riff comes on,it stops being anything else.
But is anyone listening?
harneet.singh@expressindia.com